Let's keep this thread on topic, based on the OP please.
No golden ratio discussions.
Let's keep this thread on topic, based on the OP please.
No golden ratio discussions.
All comments made in red are moderator comments. Please, read the rules of the forum here and read the additional rules for ATM, and for conspiracy theories. If you think a post is inappropriate, don't comment on it in thread but report it using the /!\ button in the lower left corner of each message. But most of all, have fun!
Catch me on twitter: @tusenfem
Catch Rosetta Plasma Consortium on twitter: @Rosetta_RPC
That makes sense and I was curious what size vector the c.f. is relative to the other two. Solving for a 1 kg mass where the two grav. forces act equally upon it, it is just shy of the actual L1 by a factor of...5.79! Wow. If my napkin work is correct, that's surprising, huh?
iphone
Last edited by George; 2018-Feb-01 at 09:55 PM.
We know time flies, we just can't see its wings.
My bold. Not at all surprising. The booby trap here is thinking in terms of a static solution, when in fact we have orbital motion to consider. The Sun's force at L1 is vastly stronger, but the Earth's component creates just enough of an offset that a spacecraft there can orbit the Sun at that shorter radius in one year. As Ken G has shown above, this is a situation where the rotating frame of reference with its fictitious centrifugal force is a handy device for calculation.
What did you use for the mass ratio between the two bodies? If the bodies are equal mass, the L1 is at the barycenter and there's no centrifugal contribution. If one body is way more massive than the other, the balance is all between the big gravity and the centrifugal force. (The mass of the test particle is of no consequence.)
I suppose the fact that the c.f. wasn't addressed until Ken's post led me to assume it was more of a tweak than the dominant vector. So much so that erroneous math won't be too surprising, huh? [I stumbled in obtaining an exact solution with these simple three vectors; the algebra got tricky for me, though I'm on the run using iPhone & iPad.]
We know time flies, we just can't see its wings.
Yeah, it's no tweak, it's key.
Sun & Earth, thus I can steal the actual L1 and compare it to my calculated point where the grav force balance for any given mass, giving the difference factor of 5.79 (using 1.5M km for L1).
. Good point, pun unintended.If the bodies are equal mass, the L1 is at the barycenter and there's no centrifugal contribution.Right since this mass cancels in the equations, but I mentioned it to separate it from the earlier point about gravitational forces being equal, which is true but different for our test mass.(The mass of the test particle is of no consequence.)
We know time flies, we just can't see its wings.